Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Garden Salad
American
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak
About
UnCommon Pizza
Welcome to UnCommon Pizza, a hidden gem tucked away in the charming town of Lititz, Pennsylvania. Located at 616 Paxton Pl #104, this delightful eatery invites you to indulge in a unique and flavorful pizza experience. With a focus on fresh ingredients and bold flavors, it's no wonder that locals rave about the delicious offerings from this cozy pizzeria.
At UnCommon Pizza, you'll find a delightful menu that goes beyond your typical pizza joint. From traditional favorites to innovative creations, every dish here presents an opportunity for culinary exploration. The specialty pizza slices are particularly noteworthy, featuring crowd-pleasers like the BBQ Chicken and Buffalo Chicken slices, each bursting with flavors that satisfy even the heartiest appetites.
For those seeking lighter fare, the selection of salads is equally impressive. The Greek Salad combines vibrant mixed greens, kalamata olives, and feta cheese to create a refreshing complement to your meal. Diners have praised the quality of the ingredients, as well as the generous portion sizes that offer great value for your money.
A standout highlight is the attention to detail in the crust—a blend of pan and thin styles that achieves a delightful crispiness without being overly greasy. One visitor, Joel Henry, described it as “very fresh and tasty,” praising the great balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings that elevate the entire pizza experience.
But UnCommon Pizza isn’t just about the pizza. Their Puppy Plate is a charming addition that caters to your furry friends, offering a delightful treat for those who want to bring their pets along. With homemade doggie ice cream and pup-friendly options, it’s a testament to the warm and welcoming atmosphere that this pizzeria fosters.
Thanks to its personable staff and inviting environment, dining in feels like gathering with friends. Customers like Elizabeth Harvey have appreciated the hot, fresh pizzas that arrive ready to delight, and the cleanliness of the dining area is another highlight that has not gone unnoticed. Coupled with an easy-access location and ample parking, UnCommon Pizza makes for a fantastic spot for family outings or a casual meal with friends.
In a time when many businesses have faced challenges, the new owners of UnCommon Pizza have evidently embraced the chance to maintain and even enhance the quality that fans have come to expect. From crispy onion rings to innovative pizzas, it’s clear that they are committed to making their mark on the local culinary scene.
Whether you're a long-time patron or new to the area, UnCommon Pizza promises a memorable dining experience worth savoring. Stop by, grab a slice, and discover why this place has quickly become a favorite destination for pizza enthusiasts in Lititz.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ We got a Plain (10") with pineapple and a Plain (10") with mushrooms and chicken. These are the oerfect size for individual tastes. Prices are decent. Hot on arrival. Great crust. We got take out this time but have dined IN in the past. Nice location. Plenty of parking. Easy in. Easy out. Personable staff. ”
“ Tucked away seemingly in the middle of a housing development, this little joint is worth the hunt. The pizza was very fresh and tasty. Not a “thin and greasy” style of pizza, more of an in between pan and thin. The sauce, cheese and toppings had great flavor. I especially liked the crust, something about it tasted nice but I couldn’t place it. I also had a side of Loaded Fries and they lasted about 2 minutes around my family. They were very good. Service was great for an early Saturday lunch. Dining room was very clean. The prices are average, 16in pizza w/ topping, loaded fries and 1 soda costs 26. Overall, worth checking out when in the area. They also have a full bar but I don’t drink, it looked very clean though. ”
“ We have been a customer since it opened. We frequented it about 5 6 times a ayear. Always a great pizza. However, after the Covid, we have had no chance to eat there. We went there tody and found that the ownership has changed. Worrited that new owners ma yhave changed the recipe. Well, since we are already there and hungry, we deiced to eat there anyways. For a change this time we ordered the Onion Rings, and all vegetarian pizza. I will categoricly state that I never, ever, had such Onion Rings in my adult life for the last 60 years. They were extra cripsy when hot, warm as well as cold. Wow! Please try that item. With the ranch dressing and ketchup it was heavenly. Keep the same recipe, please. Pizza was the same as beefore. New owners, you are doing a great job. Thanks for serving Lititz community. Pat Shah ”
“ The new owners did an amazing job catering our graduation! They were flexible, incredibly reasonable pricing and the food was terrific. ”
“ Awesome food, very fresh, and for a great price. Lots of TVs for your favorite sports teams along with a great atmosphere of sports lovers. ”
“ Best pizza I've found in Lancaster yet and I've been searching for 2 years. The buffalo chicken pizza is also much better than chain restaurants. Excited to see what the upcoming menu revamp will bring. ”
“ Just had the most amazing experience at Uncommon Pizza! This place is a hidden gem that perfectly blends family fun with pet-friendly vibes. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with a warm atmosphere and a menu that boasts unique toppings and flavors that make each slice a delightful adventure. The staff was incredibly welcoming and even brought out a special treat for our furry friend! The outdoor seating area is perfect for families and pets alike, allowing us to enjoy our meal while our pup played happily nearby. And let me tell you, the pizza was out of this world! Fresh ingredients and creative combinations that had everyone at the table raving. If you’re looking for a spot where you can enjoy delicious pizza while making memories with your family and pets, Uncommon Pizza is a must-visit! Can’t wait to go back! #UncommonPizza #FamilyFriendly #PetFriendly #PizzaLovers ”
“ We ordered pizza here for my son's birthday party. Everyone at the party said it was amazing. I placed the order the day before and the staff was very accommodating! Highly recommend. ”